Discussions · The Reading

Another One of Those Unresolved Debates: Blogging VS Vlogging – A Discussion

Lately, I’ve gotten into the habit of listening to video essays on YouTube while I’m at work (because I’m awesome at multitasking like that πŸ˜€ ). Especially video analyses of books, movies, and TV shows like Avatar: The Last Airbender (seriously, there are SO MANY videos about this show and how it does pretty much everything right), Game of Thrones, Disney movies, etc. But after watching a bunch of YouTube videos, specifically of the bookish variety, I’ve started thinking about the reasons why I chose to start a blog instead of a YouTube Channel.

Last time, I’ve talked about Video Games VS Books, so today I’m going to talk about Blogging VS Vlogging. Now, I’m not saying either blogging or vlogging is better than the other, I just want to point out the differences and what I think about them. So after sitting down and really thinking about my reasons, I boiled it down to 3 main points: Expression, Privacy, and Effort (for both the creator and the audience)

Okay, here we go!

E x p r e s s i o n

This is something I’ve always stressed about whenever I’m writing. It’s the reason why I prefer face-to-face conversations over texting. So many times when I send texts to my friends, they fail to realize that I’m being sarcastic. And if I don’t have my sarcasm, whatΒ doΒ I have?Β I’m always very expressive when I talk. I have all the hand gestures, the random bursts into song, using dramatic quotes from movies and overall just being a drama queen. So I often worry that my drama queen-ness isn’t being translated well in text form.

kermit-the-frog-flail
This is me when I’m talking

Maybe this could be where vlogging takes the point. In a video, you can gesticulate and speak dramatically to your heart’s content and people can get a good laugh out of it. You can get your point across with fewer words as long as you have the appropriate intonation and gestures.

With blogging, I find it more difficult, and often I find myself writing more, just to get the same effect. Like, am I being sarcastic? Am I wildly waving my arms around to prove a point? Who can know? Sure, GIFs, pictures, and tools likeΒ bold,Β italicized, CAPITAL letters help, but I don’t think it’s the same.


P r i v a c y

I think this one is pretty self-explanatory. It’s also the main reason why I chose to have a blog rather than a YouTube channel. I like the privacy that blogs provide. Writing for a blog, you don’t have to show your face or even your real name if you don’t want to. You can write a post while sitting in your pajamas, eating chocolate cake before you even shower in the morning, and no one will ever know! As for vlogging, unless you only do voiceovers, your face is there for the world to see.

There isn’t anything wrong with that, of course. Some people are really good and confident on camera. But that isn’t the case for everyone. That’s where blogging comes in. Blogs provide a platform for people whoΒ want to share their thoughts and opinions but not comfortable enough to be on camera.Β As dramatic as I am in real life situations, I actually get very camera shy. It’s weird for me to talk normally, facing a camera when there’s no one there to listen. I’d end up stuttering or laughing for no reason, and it’ll end up taking more time than it actually needs.

Can't

And for this section, I’m also talking about the audience. I don’t know about you, but reading blogs always feel more ‘private’ to me than watching videos, or at least it feels more alone. I can always take my time reading blog posts and not have to worry about keeping up with another person, especially since I tend to get distracted and by the time I zone back in I wouldn’t know what the speaker was talking about.


E f f o r t

For ‘effort’, I’m going to break it down to 2 sides: the content creators and the audience.

First, we’ll talk about the content creators. For content creators, of course, we’d want to produce great content that people would think is worth reading/watching. And to do that, content creators would put in a lot of effort into the things that they create,Β including research, coming up with a draft, getting links together, etc.

blogging
This is what happens when the ideas run out

For bloggers, our ‘blogging process’ include typing, spellcheck, searching for images or even taking photos for the blog post. It may sound easy, but it does take up time, especially with the research and drafting. For vloggers, they have to film and edit their videos, which to me, sounds super difficult because I know next to nothing about editing videos. And not to mention, they actually have to get ready and look presentable before filming! Because honestly, I’ve never seen a booktube video where the vlogger is in pajamas.

The audience, on the other hand, can just sit back, relax, and consume the content!

I’m just kidding. Or am I?

I guess you can say that blogs need more effort to read. You’d need to focus and you definitely can’t multitask. If you can read an article while working at the same time, then please teach me your ways! But with videos, it really takes minimal effort to consume. Like I said earlier, you can listen to the video while still doing something else. And it’s also faster to listen to videos than to read.

According to Entrepreneur.com, we use different brain processes when reading and watching videos. Reading is an active process while watching is passive, so that means your brain works harder when you read. Videos are less strenuous on the brain and need less energy and effort to watch. Maybe that’s why videos are so widely consumed today.


When I did my internship doing digital marketing, I discovered that by 2019, videos will account for 80% of all internet consumption and that videos will get you a lot more interaction than other forms of content. Videos are convenient, accessible and present quick, rich content.

So does that mean text is dying? Or does it mean people are simply getting lazier, especially since watching videos is less demanding and take up a lot less energy? It could be true because the majority of students prefer watching movie adaptation than reading the books when I did my research last year.

It’s for that reason I’m always very cautious whenever I’m writing a blog post. I’m worried that my posts are too long and people would just stop reading half-way.

enough
What I imagine people are thinking when reading my longer posts

But when I did a little more digging, I found out that 85% of Facebook videos, which are essentially shared from other platforms, are watched without sound (DigiDay)! So that means, people rely on the images and subtitles to know what the video is about. Doesn’t that mean they’re still reading anyway?

Apparently, watching videos mean we’re unconsciously ‘letting go of our perception of absolute control over our environment’ (Entrepreneur), which leads to watching videos being a form of escapism. But that doesn’t work for everyone. There are people who want to remain in control, and those people would prefer text. Reading allows us to reread paragraphs, skim over less interesting parts and generally lets us set the pace.


Personally, I definitely prefer blogging over vlogging. It’s not just about the privacy issue, although that’s a pretty big part of it, but also because I feel that as a book blogger, it helps me see how different people would present their ideas and the way they write. It helps me practice writing because like it or not, I have to write if I want to post anything. And plus, reading other blogs just give me more reading material, so win-win for everyone!

So that’s my take on the Blogging VS Vlogging argument. I’m sure this exact discussion has been done countless times before, but I wanted to share my thoughts on it and see if I could offer something different to the table.

What do you think? Should book bloggers stay in the ‘blogging world’ or should we move on to videos to keep up with the trends? Is there anything you agree/disagree with? Let me know in the comments! I’d love to hear what you think πŸ˜€

Signature - Glamor Style

13 thoughts on “Another One of Those Unresolved Debates: Blogging VS Vlogging – A Discussion

  1. I think there’s a market here: Vlogging in PJs. That could even be the name
    But seriously, I’m like you. I can’t imagine getting in front of a camera a few times a week to vlog. Do I write a script? Do I just adlib? How do I edit? Ugh. My brain hurts.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Yeah, that would be so cool! I don’t think I’ll be able vlog, even in PJs, but I’m sure it would be fun to watch 😁
      Exactly! I probably would sound like a robot with or without a script haha
      Thanks for the comment!

      Liked by 1 person

  2. I’ve heard the same thing about videos basically being the future, and it makes me sad because I prefer blogging. I’m not sure I’d be great on camera, I don’t really have to equipment to do it, and I also like my privacy, as you mention.

    I think the watching videos without sound thing is probably people watching them at work or like on public transit.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I can definitely see the appeal of videos, but I prefer blogging, too. And plus, getting the equipment to start vlogging wouldn’t be cheap πŸ˜…

      Exactly! And also students who don’t want to be caught watching videos in class haha.

      Like

  3. I love video essays on youtube! (not that I’d ever want to do my own πŸ˜‰ ) hehehehe I love your point about the expression- I have the same problem with sarcasm in texts, so I get what you mean. But blogging does offer a great amount of privacy. I honestly prefer blogging too- you make a great point about being inspired by other blogs πŸ˜€

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Happy to hear you agree with my points! It’s so frustrating when people don’t get my sarcasm through text haha
      But if you ever do become a YouTuber, I bet you’d make really funny videos! Just based on your posts πŸ˜€ πŸ˜€

      Like

  4. This is an incredibly interesting topic and I really love the way you broke it down into those three points. To be honest, sometimes when I write something I suddenly wish I was doing a video because I can hear myself say those words in my head and I just know that I could get them across so much better if the readers would hear it too. But, like you said. Videos would require me to show my face and that thought probably shouldn’t be as terrifying as it is. (But I already struggle enough with putting pictures of myself on my Instagram, so)
    As for the whole ‘videos are the future’ thing that every statistics I’ve ever seen confirms, I guess I just wonder if it really is as big a problem as it’s made out to be. Yes, videos are incredibly popular. But like you said, they can be watched while you do anything else, so if I start watching videos every time I clean up my room, I’m adding to those numbers even though I might still read the same amount of blog posts that I’ve always done. If that makes sense?
    And well, I think bloggers who don’t have issues with being on camera could profit from starting a Youtube channel or something similar, but more because experimenting with new platforms can teach you a lot? You learn how to edit videos, how to get the lighting right etc, and that might be valuable experience. But I don’t think we’re at a time where bloggers are forced to make videos if they want to still have an audience and I don’t believe (or maybe just very much hope) that we’ll get there any time soon.
    Sorry for all the rambling, I meant to keep this short. But your post really got me thinking because it’s such an interesting topic. And yeah, just gonna shut up now πŸ™‚

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I get what you mean. Sometimes I wish I did videos instead, especially when I’m trying to say something that’s meant to be funny. It’s just so much easier to deliver humor when you can say it a certain way and time it just right. But I don’t think I want my face to be on the internet just yet haha…

      That totally makes sense! Multitasking is one of the main reasons I watch videos, other than the occasional make-up tutorial and funny videos where I actually have to pay attention πŸ˜€ . But other than that, I prefer to be doing something while listening because I don’t like feeling passive. I don’t think it would be a problem if people watch a ton of videos, but I also think that people should know when to have self-control (I’ve seen people binge-watch videos for HOURS) because I feel like watching and listening to someone else talk about something or doing something doesn’t really engage our brains as much as reading does. But maybe I’m wrong, I don’t know.

      Definitely agree with you about starting a YouTube career. All the skills we’d learn from producing videos could be the added advantage we need when looking for a job. Of course, it depends on what kind of job we’re looking at. I also agree that bloggers don’t need to switch to videos to gain an audience, especially those of us who blog about books. I mean, we’re all about reading, right?

      Thank you so much for the comment! Don’t worry about keeping things short, I absolutely loved reading your comment! I’d love to discuss more topics with you soon πŸ™‚

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Yeah, exactly! Humor especially is difficult to ‘get right’ when you write because you can’t rely on tone and expression to get it across the way you want to. And I don’t think you ever have to be ready if you don’t want to. But if you one day feel different about it, I’m sure a lot of your followers would be interested in seeing what you come up with πŸ™‚

        Okay, in the defense of binge-watching, it can be really fun. (Admittedly, I’m thinking more about watching all three Lord of the Rings movies one after another instead of Youtube, but I’m sure the same concept applies.) More importantly, I also like to binge-read, and I’m honestly not sure if one is ‘better’ than the other *shrug* I do get your point, and I do think it’s true to a certain extend, but I think it also depends a lot son what type of video you’re watching and how much attention you’re willing to pay it. (Like statistic videos. My brain is definitely engaged there *sigh*)

        Well, I definitely am, and I’m sure other readers agree with me πŸ™‚ And yeah, exactly. Video skills can be especially helpful if you want to get into social media marketing or journalism one day, but I’m sure there are many other applications as well!

        Haha, I’m glad to hear that! (As you can see, I really suck at keeping things short… but don’t feel obligated to respond, I really tend to ramble) So would I, I’m sure we’ll find things to talk about πŸ˜€

        Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.